Cold Brew Maker

Toddy Cold Brew System

by Toddy

4.5
★★★★★ 4.5 / 5

The Toddy Cold Brew System remains a favorite among home cold brew enthusiasts for its simplicity, large batch capacity, and ability to produce smooth, low-acid concentrate at a fraction of the cost of specialty cafe drinks.

  • 1-gallon capacity brewing container
  • Reusable felt filter plus optional paper filters
  • Two glass storage decanters with lids included
  • Patented no-drip rubber stopper valve
4.5/5
Editor score 90%
#38 of 59 · Cold Brew Maker
Check price on AliExpress →
Editor reviewedHands-on testedIndependent pick
⚖ Add to Brew-Off comparison

We earn a small commission on qualifying purchases via AliExpress affiliate links — at no extra cost to you.

The verdict

The Toddy Cold Brew System remains a favorite among home cold brew enthusiasts for its simplicity, large batch capacity, and ability to produce smooth, low-acid concentrate at a fraction of the cost of specialty cafe drinks. While the felt filter requires some maintenance and the brew time demands patience, the payoff in flavor quality and value makes it a worthwhile investment for regular cold brew drinkers.

At a glance

Our full review

The Toddy Cold Brew System has earned its reputation as the gold standard for home cold brew coffee makers, and it's easy to see why once you understand its refreshingly simple design. The system consists of a durable BPA-free plastic brewing container, a reusable felt filter, a rubber stopper, and a glass decanter, all working together through a straightforward immersion brewing process. Coarsely ground coffee steeps in room temperature water for twelve to twenty-four hours, allowing the natural extraction to draw out rich flavor while leaving behind the oils and acids responsible for the bitterness and stomach upset many people associate with hot-brewed coffee. The result is a smooth, low-acid concentrate that can be diluted with hot water, milk, or ice depending on your mood.

What sets the Toddy apart from countless cold brew gadgets flooding the market is its no-fuss, no-electricity approach to brewing. There are no batteries, buttons, or complicated assembly instructions involved. You simply add your ground coffee, pour in filtered water, let gravity and time do their work, then release the stopper to let the concentrate filter down into the glass decanter below. This concentrate keeps well in the refrigerator for up to two weeks, meaning one brewing session can supply your coffee needs for days, whether you're making a single cup or entertaining guests who prefer their coffee cold and smooth rather than hot and sharp.

Beyond coffee, the Toddy system doubles beautifully for cold brew tea, making it a versatile addition to any kitchen counter for those who enjoy both beverages. The felt filters are washable and reusable, cutting down on paper waste, though replacement filters are readily available for those who prefer a fresh one each brew. Cleanup is minimal since the components separate easily for rinsing, and the glass decanter is dishwasher safe for added convenience. For anyone serious about consistently smooth, café-quality cold brew without investing in an expensive machine, the Toddy Cold Brew System remains a trusted, tried-and-true choice that continues to win over coffee enthusiasts year after year.

Specs & ratings

Brew Capacity1 gallon (3.8 liters)
Steep Time12-24 hours
Filter TypeReusable felt or paper
MaterialBPA-free plastic bucket, glass decanters
Included ComponentsBrewing container, 2 decanters, felt filter, stopper

Pros & cons

👍 What we liked

  • Produces smooth, low-acid cold brew concentrate
  • Large batch size lasts several weeks
  • Simple manual process with no electricity needed
  • Reusable felt filter reduces long-term costs
  • Glass decanters keep concentrate fresh in the fridge
  • Affordable compared to countertop cold brew machines

👎 Worth noting

  • Felt filter requires hand washing and can retain odors over time
  • Steeping process takes 12-24 hours before coffee is ready
  • Bucket design takes up notable fridge or counter space
  • Occasional grounds sediment can pass into concentrate
  • Paper filters are an added recurring cost if preferred

What owners are saying

★★★★★

Best cold brew I've made at home

I've tried several cold brew methods and this one produces the smoothest, richest concentrate by far. The felt filter really cuts down on sediment compared to my old mason jar method.

MMarcus D. · 2023-06-14
★★★★★

Great flavor, some upkeep required

The coffee tastes amazing and lasts me almost two weeks. Just wish the felt filter didn't need special cleaning care between batches - I sometimes swap in paper filters instead.

EElena R. · 2023-08-02
★★★★★

Perfect for daily cold brew drinkers

Once I got my ratio and timing down, this system produces cafe-quality concentrate every time. The glass decanters are a nice touch for storage in the fridge.

JJason P. · 2023-04-19
★★★★★

Simple and effective

No electricity, no fuss - just good, strong cold brew. Takes up some fridge space but the batch size makes it worth it for my household.

PPriya S. · 2023-09-10